We found out only the other day that Afghan/Taliban leader, Mullah Omar, died about two year ago. We may take a good deal more time admitting to ourselves (if we ever really do) that -- in Afghanistan -- we have lost yet another war. The Taliban have won.
The international conflict that Mullah Omar helped to start in 2001 is still going on, having cost, thus far, the lives of an estimated ninety-one thousand Afghans, twenty-six thousand of them civilians. Three thousand three hundred and ninety-three soldiers from twenty-nine different countries died, too, the majority of them—two thousand three hundred and sixteen—Americans. The financial cost to U.S. taxpayers alone has been around a trillion dollars, with billions more to come, in the years ahead, in medical bills and other long-term costs for Afghan-war veterans. Although the American combat role in the Afghan war officially ended last December, about ten thousand troops have stayed on as advisers and as a counterterrorism quick-reaction force within a reconstituted NATO mission, and will remain at least through the end of 2016.
Mullah Omar’s Taliban survived NATO’s extended presence in Afghanistan. In some ways, it can be argued that it defeated it. After being dislodged from power by the initial U.S. military assault launched in 2001, the Taliban eventually revived and now has an increasingly robust presence in many parts of the country, leaving Afghanistan in a chronically precarious state. ...JonLeeAnderson,NewYorker
Sometimes someone on the right pops up -- Lindsey Graham among others, at least this time, along with "bomb,bomb, bomb" McCain -- advocating for a whole new war.
This time it may well be Iran. We begin to understand that Republicans (who also love war for its ability to generate even more campaign support from the defense establishment) want each successive war to somehow erase or justify or drown out our memorites of the most recent debacle.
Both Iraq and Afghanistan are have been clear and costly failures and both have been the exclusive property of the American right and its donors -- with the American people, as fall guys, paying heavily for both wars. An Iraq war was a gift from Bush#2 and meant (somehow) to make President Bush#1 feel better after a snub. Action in Afghanistan would re-erect the World Trade Center as well as some Republican leaders who had been feeling impotent. As the truth of all this trickles down to the rest of us -- we pay the bills -- Republicans will try to find another war to fight that we'll pay for later. In the meantime, they'd like us to forget that the Taliban have won and ISIS is close behind. We're stuck with the consequences: Taliban and ISIS damage, photos of the family members we lost, and our post-war financial situations.
Not to mention the kind of "security" we have given the people of Afghanistan.
Here is the enemy we didn't defeat -- remember? Before Bush and Cheney rushed in to, um, get rid of the bad guys?
In one of their very first acts in Kabul, Taliban fighters stormed the United Nations compound in Kabul and seized the former Afghan President, Mohammad Najibullah, who had taken refuge there since his overthrow, in 1992. The Taliban beat him, castrated him, dragged him behind a jeep, shot him, and then hanged him. This act set the tone for the Taliban’s subsequent rule: they massacred members of the Hazara minority for being Shiites, banned women from working in hospitals or any public offices, and kept girls out of schools; they banned public music, the sale of CDs, and kite flying. Kabul’s sports stadium became an execution ground. In March, 2001, Mullah Omar’s men blew up the two giant stone Buddhas of Bamiyan, archaeological treasures that were fifteen hundred years old. ...JonLeeAnderson,NewYorker
Well, Bush and Cheney didn't succeed in making them go away. They're still there.